William H. Ukers (author)
Padang Green | | Padang Roasted | | | | Guatemala Green | | | | | Guatemala Roasted | | | | | | Mocha Green | | | | | | | Mocha | | | | | | | Roasted | | | | | | | | Water extract 31.11 30.30 30.83
judge verdicts (4)
- groundedness 1.00 pass — The claim is directly stated in the passage. The table clearly shows 'Water extract' as a row, and the value 30.83 is listed under the 'Padang Green' column, exactly as claimed.
- qualifier_fidelity 0.60 fail — The quote provided ('Water extract 31.11 30.30 30.83') does not accurately support the claim. The table shows water extract values across multiple coffee types in order: Santos Green (31.11), Santos Roasted (30.30), Padang Green (30.83), Padang Roasted (30.21), etc. While 30.83 is indeed the correct value for Padang Green, the quote as formatted is misleading because it conflates values from three different coffee varieties. The quote should isolate only the Padang Green column value. Additionally, the context qualifier is empty when it should specify this is for the 'dry' or 'as-is' state of the beans (or clarify the measurement basis, as some measurements have 'dry basis' variants shown in the table). The quote fidelity is compromised by including adjacent values without clear delineation.
- groundedness 1.00 pass — The claim is directly stated in the passage. The table clearly shows that Padang Green has a water extract value of 30.83, which can be read from the row labeled 'Water extract' aligned with the Padang Green column.
- qualifier_fidelity 0.75 pass — The claim correctly identifies Padang Green's water extract content as 30.83 from the passage table. The perspective (viewpoint: 'author', stance: 'asserts', sentiment: 'neutral') is appropriate for a factual data assertion. Time qualifiers are correctly null since the passage provides no temporal scope for these measurements. However, the quote is unnecessarily verbose and poorly formatted - it includes irrelevant column headers and intermediate data. A cleaner quote would be just the "Water extract" row showing "30.83" for Padang Green, making it more clearly support the claim. All qualifiers are faithful, but the quote quality slightly reduces clarity.