An Unflattened Identity and Change Knowledge Graph

clubs unspecified sense

concept · 1 mention

Social organizations that evolved from coffee house groups

Connections

The concepts, people, and places this entity is most linked to by claims — node size is mention count, colour is type, dashed nodes are other senses of the same word.

clubscoffee-houses — 2 shared claimscoffee houses at beginning of century — 1 shared claimmen — 1 shared claimcoffee-housescoffee houses at be…men
ConceptPlace

Defining properties

Perspectives

Claims grouped by the voice that makes them.

William H. Ukers (author)

  • clubs took care of social functions of coffee houses
    clubs were organized to take care of the social functions
    judge verdicts (2)
    • groundedness 0.70 pass — The claim is directly supported by the passage. The text explicitly states 'clubs were organized to take care of the social functions' of the coffee houses, which matches the claim's predicate and object with only minor rewording from the original passage.
    • qualifier_fidelity 1.00 pass — All qualifiers are faithful to the passage. The viewpoint is correctly attributed to the author (the passage is written from the author's perspective, not citing a named source). The stance 'asserts' is appropriate as the passage states this as fact. The sentiment 'neutral' matches the passage's objective tone. The time qualifiers are correctly null as the passage provides no specific dates or temporal scope for this statement. The context is appropriately empty as the passage does not restrict the claim to a particular sense or role. The quote 'clubs were organized to take care of the social functions' appears verbatim in the passage and directly supports the claim about clubs taking over social functions that coffee houses previously provided.
  • men have coffee houses as clubs now
    Men had their coffee houses as now they have their clubs
    judge verdicts (2)
    • groundedness 1.00 pass — The claim is directly stated in the passage with the exact quote provided: 'Men had their coffee houses as now they have their clubs.' This is a straightforward comparison made by the author between coffee houses of the past and clubs of the present day.
    • qualifier_fidelity 0.80 pass — The claim is largely faithful. The viewpoint, stance, and sentiment are all correct - the passage presents this as a general authorial assertion in neutral tone. The quote is verbatim. However, the time qualifier has a minor issue: the claim uses 'when: "now"' which represents the time of the original passage (18th century), but this creates ambiguity since "now" is relative to the passage's period, not an absolute temporal reference. The normalized dates are null, which is appropriate since the passage doesn't provide specific dates. The context is correctly left empty as the passage doesn't restrict the claim to a specific sense or role. Overall, the qualifiers are faithful with only a slight temporal ambiguity that doesn't substantially undermine the claim.
  • coffee houses superseded by clubs in philadelphia clubs ⟨Philadelphia⟩
    Phila., supersede c. houses
    judge verdicts (2)
    • groundedness 0.70 pass — The passage directly states 'Phila., supersede c. houses' under the Clubs section, which supports the claim that clubs superseded coffee houses in Philadelphia. The abbreviations 'c.' and 'Phila.' are clearly interpreted as 'coffee' and 'Philadelphia' based on context, making this a minor rewording of what is explicitly stated in the index.
    • qualifier_fidelity 0.90 pass — Nearly all qualifiers are faithful to the passage. The quote is accurate and supports the claim. Viewpoint, stance, sentiment, time, and context all appropriately reflect the passage entry 'Phila., supersede c. houses, 130'. Minor note: the abbreviation 'c.' in the original stands for 'coffee', which the claim correctly expands to 'coffee houses'. The only negligible issue is that the passage presents this as a bare reference/index entry rather than a full authored assertion, but this is typical for index-style passages and does not warrant score deduction.

unspecified sources

  • clubs numbered as many as coffee houses at beginning of century end of the century ⟨at end of eighteenth century⟩
    It is said there were as many clubs at the end of the century as there were coffee houses at the beginning
    judge verdicts (4)
    • groundedness 1.00 pass — The claim is directly stated in the passage with an exact quote. The passage explicitly says 'It is said there were as many clubs at the end of the century as there were coffee houses at the beginning,' which precisely matches the subject, predicate, and object of the claim.
    • qualifier_fidelity 0.60 fail — VIEWPOINT QUALIFIER UNFAITHFUL: The claim attributes the statement to 'author' but the passage uses 'It is said' which indicates an attribution to unspecified sources or common knowledge, not the author. The viewpoint should reflect this indirect/passive attribution rather than claiming direct authorial assertion. Additionally, the quote is accurate and the time qualifiers are appropriate for the eighteenth century context.
    • groundedness 1.00 pass — The claim is directly stated in the passage with a matching quote: 'It is said there were as many clubs at the end of the century as there were coffee houses at the beginning.' The subject (clubs), predicate (numbered as many as), and object (coffee houses at beginning of century) are all explicitly present in the source text.
    • qualifier_fidelity 0.80 pass — The claim is mostly faithful to the passage. The quote is accurate and the time qualifiers are correct (end of century, valid_to: 1799). The context appropriately specifies the eighteenth century setting. The viewpoint correctly uses 'unspecified sources' as the passage attributes the statement to 'It is said' rather than a named source. However, the stance qualifier should be 'reported/It is said' rather than 'asserts' to more precisely reflect the passage's hedging language ('It is said'), which indicates this is attributed hearsay rather than a direct assertion.

Change over time

end of the century
  • numbered as many as coffee houses at beginning of century
now
  • have coffee houses as men