Macaulay and Doherty
experience has shown we can expect no permanent advantage from it
judge verdicts (4)
- groundedness 1.00 pass — The claim is directly supported by the passage. Macaulay and Doherty explicitly state 'Desirable as would be the concession by America of the right of mutual search, experience has shown we can expect no permanent advantage from it,' which directly matches the claim's assertion that mutual search does not provide permanent advantage.
- qualifier_fidelity 0.60 fail — The predicate 'provides' is unfaithful to the passage. The quoted text explicitly states 'we can expect no permanent advantage from it', which means the concession does NOT provide permanent advantage. The predicate should be 'provides' negated or reformulated as 'does not provide' or the object should be 'no permanent advantage'. Additionally, the stance qualifier 'disputes' is not quite accurate - the passage expresses a negative empirical claim based on experience ('experience has shown'), not a dispute or questioning of another's position. The stance should be 'negative' or 'denies' rather than 'disputes'. The viewpoint, sentiment (negative), time (null), context (empty), and quote are all faithful to the passage.
- groundedness 1.00 pass — The claim is directly stated in the passage. Macaulay and Doherty explicitly write: 'Desirable as would be the concession by America of the right of mutual search, experience has shown we can expect no permanent advantage from it.' This exactly matches the subject, predicate, and object of the claim.
- qualifier_fidelity 1.00 pass — All qualifiers are faithful to the passage. The viewpoint correctly attributes the statement to Macaulay and Doherty as named sources. The stance is appropriately 'asserts' rather than 'disputes' or 'questions'. The sentiment is correctly marked as negative, matching the pessimistic tone of the quoted text. The time qualifiers are appropriately null since the passage provides no specific temporal scope for this particular claim about permanent advantage. The context is empty as appropriate since no specific contextual restriction is needed. The quote 'experience has shown we can expect no permanent advantage from it' appears verbatim in the passage and directly supports the claim.
